When it comes to college applications, your essay is often the one place where you can set yourself apart beyond numbers and achievements. But too many students fall into the same traps — writing what they think admissions officers want to hear, or forcing a story that doesn’t feel real. Let’s break down five common mistakes and show you how to steer clear of them.
1. Writing to Impress Instead of to Express
Many students think they need to sound overly intellectual or use big words to impress. The result? Essays that feel stiff, unnatural, or worse — insincere.
How to avoid it: Write like you speak, but cleaner. Your essay should sound like you on your best day — thoughtful, clear, and genuine. Admissions officers want to get to know you, not your thesaurus.
2. Choosing Topics That Aren’t Truly Personal
Some students pick topics because they “seem impressive,” like volunteering trips or a big win in sports, even if these moments didn’t actually change them much.
How to avoid it: The best essays come from stories only you can tell. That could be a quiet realization, a family tradition, or a challenge you faced that others might overlook. Look for moments of growth and self-discovery — not just achievements.
3. Being Too Generic or Vague
Statements like “I learned the value of hard work” or “I grew as a person” don’t say much. Generic essays blend together and leave no impression.
How to avoid it: Get specific. Show us what you learned through small, vivid details. What did it look like, sound like, feel like? If someone else could write your essay, it’s time to dig deeper.
4. Telling a Story Without Reflection
Some students write a play-by-play of an event but forget to include why it matters. Admissions teams aren’t just looking for what happened — they care how it shaped you.
How to avoid it: Always connect your story back to who you are today. What did it change in your values, goals, or perspective? Reflection is where your voice truly comes through.
5. Not Editing Enough
A first draft is rarely your best draft. Many students stop after a few tweaks, missing the chance to elevate their essay from “fine” to unforgettable.
How to avoid it: Give yourself plenty of time to revise. Read it aloud. Share it with someone who’ll give you honest feedback. Often, what you think is clear might need more work — and that’s okay. Editing is where good essays become great.
Final Thoughts
Your college essay is a chance to show a side of you that grades and test scores can’t. By avoiding these common mistakes, you’ll be on your way to writing something genuine, memorable, and uniquely yours.
Need expert eyes on your essay? Our team at My Ivy Advisor would love to help you shape your story. Get in touch with us today for honest feedback and thoughtful guidance.
